Roof second opinions · Victoria, BC
Roof second opinion: what it is, and when you need one.
Been told you need a new roof? Before you sign a five-figure contract, get the verdict from a Red Seal roofer who isn’t selling you one. $249 flat, in writing, with photos — repair, maintain, or replace, and the reasons why.
What it is
A roof second opinion is a paid, independent verdict on a claim somebody else has made about your roof — most often “you need a new one.” I inspect the roof myself, I read the quote or claim line by line, and you get the answer in writing: repair, maintain, or replace, with photos and the reasons. The fee is $249 flat. It is a named, priced product in the inspection world — firms that do not sell or install roofs charge $199 and up for exactly this — and as far as I can tell, nobody else in Victoria offers it. The service also lives on the inspections page, next to the full condition report.
What it covers
- The roof itself — I inspect it personally: field, seams, flashings, drainage, and the attic side if it matters.
- The claim — the quote, estimate or insurance position you were given, reviewed line by line against what is actually up there.
- The verdict — repair, maintain, or replace, in plain writing, with photos and the reasoning shown.
- The fair scope — if replacement really is right, what the job should include, so you can compare bids properly. Bid review afterwards, if you want it.
When you need one
- A big quote landed. Five figures, a “free inspection” that found a dead roof, and a discount if you sign this week. That combination deserves a $249 test before it deserves your signature.
- An insurance dispute. The insurer says the roof is old or the damage is wear; you say otherwise. An independent Red Seal report with photos is the document that argument needs.
- You’re buying a house. The roof is the biggest number in the purchase, and the home inspector’s paragraph is not a roofer’s verdict. Get it before the subjects come off.
- You’re a strata council. A contractor has handed you a replacement number you cannot judge. The verdict gives council something defensible to minute — and the same roof data feeds your depreciation report.
- Two quotes disagree wildly. One of them is missing scope or inventing it. A third read, from somebody with no bid in the fight, settles it.
Second opinion or full inspection?
| Second opinion — $249 | Full inspection — $349 | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts from | A claim: a quote, a replacement recommendation, an insurance position | The roof itself |
| You receive | A written verdict on the claim, photos, and a fair scope if replacement is right | A 20-point written condition report, photos tied to a roof plan, remaining-life estimate, prioritised fix list |
| Best for | Deciding whether to sign, pay, or dispute | Documenting the roof for records, strata, insurance, purchase or planning |
The roof inspection cost page breaks down what the $349 buys at each level, and the replacement cost guide shows the ranges a fair quote should land in. Travel for either service is $1.25 per km, round trip from Victoria — driving time and vehicle included, no separate hourly charge for the drive.
Why paid beats free: a free inspection is a sales visit — the inspector’s company earns only if you buy. A second opinion is paid the same either way, so the answer is the answer.
Frequently asked questions
What is a roof second opinion?
A paid, independent inspection of your roof and of a claim made about it — a replacement quote, an insurance position, a seller’s assurance — by a Red Seal roofer who is not trying to sell you the work. You get a written verdict: repair, maintain, or replace, with photos and the reasons. The fee is $249 flat.
What does a roof second opinion cost?
The second opinion is $249 flat. A full roof inspection with a written condition report is $349 flat. Travel is charged at $1.25 per km, round trip from Victoria — that rate covers both the driving time and the vehicle, with no separate hourly charge for driving. You will always get the price in writing before anything starts.
When should I get a second opinion on my roof?
When the stakes are high and the advice comes from someone who profits from it: a five-figure replacement quote, an insurance dispute over roof damage or age, a house purchase with the subjects about to come off, or a strata council handed a big number it cannot judge. If two quotes disagree wildly, that is also a reason — one of them is wrong.
What do I receive from a second opinion?
A written verdict you can act on: what Denis found on the roof, photos of the relevant details, a line-by-line read of the quote or claim you were given, and — if replacement really is right — what a fair scope looks like, so you can compare bids properly. It is written to be shown to the other party: the roofing company, the insurer, the seller, or the council.
How is a second opinion different from a full roof inspection?
A second opinion starts from someone else’s claim and tests it against the roof. A full inspection starts from the roof itself — a 20-point condition report with photos tied to a roof plan and a remaining-life estimate, built as a record for strata councils, insurers, buyers and your own planning. If you have a quote or a claim to test, book the second opinion; if you need the roof documented, book the inspection.
Will Denis try to sell me the replacement instead?
No. The second opinion is the product — Denis is paid the same whether the verdict is repair or replace, and he does not bid the job off the back of it. If replacement is right, you get the fair scope in writing and take it to whichever roofers you choose.
Get a second opinion
Tell me what you were told — the quote, the claim, the deadline. The fee is $249 flat, plus travel at $1.25 per km round trip from Victoria.
Prefer to talk? Call 250-889-5620 or email info@waterproofingsystems.ca.